First of all, I do believe that Tom is not guilty. I think that Tom's story was right, and after he ran away Bob Ewell must have beat Mayella up for kissing Tom. When Tom said that he had run away, Mr. Gilmer (the prosecutor) asks why he ran. He said that if Tom was such a big man, why was he afraid of Mayella? Tom responded that he ran because he was black, and he said if you were black, you would understand. This definitely proves oppression to me. He was so afraid of what might happen that he had to run away. Next, the jury all voted that Tom was guilty when Jem was sure that the evidence proved him not guilty. They only did this because Tom was black. Anyone could see that he wasn't guilty, yet the jury said he was just because he was black. I would have no doubt that if the roles were switched, a white man would be found not guilty. This angers me, because this leads to Tom getting in jail for something he didn't do. When Tom tries to escape, the guards don't hesitate to shoot him. They shot him seventeen times. They didn't just mean to stop him from running away with one shot, they meant to kill him. That is completely unnecessary, and I am so sad for Tom's wife- Helen. She had to raise so many kids on her own. And when Link Deas employed her, she would walk a mile to go out of the way of the Ewell household. When Link Deas told him to stop harassing her, she walked on the public road past the Ewell house and found Bob following her. Link Deas finally put it to an end when he threatened Bob. This makes me so mad. The trial is over, you've basically killed this woman's husband with your lying on the witness stand, can you stop bothering her? Bob just has so much prejudice inside of him, and is disrespectful and oppressive to the black people and Atticus.
Society killed Tom. I believe that the way the society was oppressive to black people was the reason that Tom was found guilty, and later killed when he tried to escape from jail. If a white person was in jail, do you think they would shoot?
I think your argument is well said. It was the oppression in society against black people that made the jury convict Tom. I also liked how you showed the contradictions and evidence present in the trial. Though the futurama meme doesn't really fit the "stop being so oppressive" in my opinion (it's just the look doesn't really work and those words don't match the meme to me). Overall good job,
ReplyDeleteThe part where you said ; "society killed Tom." I very strongly disagree the society didn't kill Tom he was killed by policemen I know that what you said was not literal but really everybody wasn't against Tom, even tho they kind of took a part in Tom being sent to jail.
ReplyDeleteYour question at the end. I don't think that if Tom were white he would have been killed just a lesser chance of him being sent to prison. Honestly I think even if Tom were a white man his victim would have blamed it on a random black man and he would have been sent to prison
ReplyDeleteI actually do agree that society killed Tom, because even though not everybody in society thought he was guilty, the large majority of people with power did, and society is made up of those people.
ReplyDelete